Select text to annotate, Click play in YouTube to begin
00:00:00
[Music] I'm going to speak about Consciousness starting from a completely different point of view I'm not starting with the
00:00:15
brain I'm not starting with cerebrocentric view of Consciousness but with the um the bigger picture it's been taken for granted by almost every civilization and traditional
00:00:29
society that there are many forms of Consciousness in the universe not just us and not just those of animals other animals um so it's been often assumed that the entire universe is conscious
00:00:42
and this these this view of Consciousness doesn't try and tie it all down to particular regions of the brain or interactions or electrical impulses going from one bit to another um it's his Consciousness in a
00:00:55
completely different way and the reason why people in all these cultures think that there are many forms of Consciousness beyond our own is because they experience them through mystical experiences through
00:01:09
Altered States Of Consciousness through spiritual practices through psychedelics traditionally taken in a number of cultures around the world people have the experience of being in contact with
00:01:21
a greater Consciousness than their own when sir Alice to Hardy in the 1960s started the religious experience Research Unit in Oxford he was asking people in Britain if they'd had
00:01:34
experiences that seemed to involve a conscious presence greater than their own mystical experiences he was astonished at thousands of reports poured in it turned out these are much more common than anyone had previously
00:01:47
thought most people don't talk about them because they were shy to do so they they're afraid they'd be classified as mentally ill or something like that and but recent surveys have shown that
00:02:00
as many as 50 percent of the population have had experiences of other kinds of reality near-death experiences spontaneous mystical experiences including ones that occur in childhood
00:02:13
and other kinds of Altered States Of Consciousness which suggest that their Consciousness is part of something greater than themselves now in in ancient Greece they had the
00:02:26
ellucinian Mysteries um most of the uh the the culture there was influenced by this kind of mystery Cult of which involved an initiation in a cave which involved taking
00:02:39
psychoactive substances we don't know what uh they were um but this was a pervasive feature of Greek philosophy and Plato in his book
00:02:50
The Time years talks about the conscious universe hmm what she says is this world came to be in very truth a living creature with soul and reason a single visible living
00:03:04
creature containing within itself all living things whose nature is of the same order so this is a vision of the entire Cosmos as a living being a living organism
00:03:16
and this kind of view was in inherited by medieval philosophers in in Europe in the universities and in the cathedral schools
00:03:28
um they were also influenced very much by the philosophy of Aristotle who thought that all living beings have souls the soul is the form of the body it's what shapes the body and it's what
00:03:40
attracts a being towards its end point at Acorn as it germinates into an oak seedling is pulled towards the mature form of an oak tree by the soul of the oak so plants have souls animals have
00:03:52
soils the planets have soils the stars have souls according to this view in fact the Greeks including Plato called the stars and the planets and the Sun the visible gods and indeed we still
00:04:07
call the planets by the names of the gods and goddesses penis Mars Mercury and so on so um in medieval Europe This was the standard world view
00:04:19
theologians like Saint Thomas Aquinas integrated this Greek View particularly Aristotle zoo with Christian theology to produce a view an animistic view of nature nature is alive the Earth is
00:04:32
alive the planets and the stars are alive they're conscious beings the whole universe is a conscious being animals and plants have souls and the human rational mind is embedded in a level of
00:04:45
the human soul which relates us to plants we're shaping our body vegetative soil shapes our bodies and underlies regeneration and wound healing the animal soul that we have we share with
00:04:58
animals gives us our animal instincts and emotions like fear hunger thirst sexual desire and so on but the rational mind is that which is specifically human and to do with conscious thought
00:05:10
language and reason and that was the standard view in the Middle Ages now the reason I'm saying all this is because it's important to realize what a completely radical break the 17th
00:05:23
century mechanistic revolution in science was with everything that had gone before in our own culture and in all others in the 17th century the Scientific Revolution was a revolution precisely
00:05:35
because it denied these traditional views for the founders of modern science nature was not a living organism it was a machine um animals and plants were not living
00:05:47
organisms they were machines automata unconscious inanimate automata the human body was a machine and in the vision of Rene Descartes
00:06:00
who's founded this mechanistic philosophy most explicitly the whole universe is made of inanimate matter which works mechanically by pushing by being pushed from the past through
00:06:13
physical mechanical causes the stars and the planets and mechanical objects made of unconscious matter the Earth's an unconscious object our body is the animal bodies are plants are the only
00:06:26
things that were not a mechanical and unconscious in the universe where God angels and human Minds basically what Descartes did was deanimate the whole of nature drain the soul out of the whole
00:06:39
of nature so that all was left in nature was inanimate matter but outside nature were God angels and human minds and God was supposed to have created the world machine in the first place by being a
00:06:51
brilliant engineer and mathematician oppressed the start button and then it was all supposed to go on more or less automatically thereafter so we have an idea of completely autonomous
00:07:02
unconscious Mechanical Universe with the only role for God left to being to start it off and to interact with human Minds which were the only non-material things left in the universe
00:07:15
this is Cartesian dualism and it dominated science for the first two or three centuries of its existence and it created three splits really a split between religion and science religion
00:07:27
got God angels and human minds and morality science got the entire physical Universe including the human body it created a split between Mind and Body in ourselves that our minds Were Somehow
00:07:41
utterly separate from our bodies and it but interacted with them in a way that was profoundly mysterious he thought it happened in the pineal gland modern cartesians think it happens in cerebral
00:07:53
cortex it's basically the same Theory it's just moved a couple of inches and the it also created a split between man and the Animals we have rational
00:08:05
conscious minds and purposes animals don't they're just machines therefore we can treat them as cruelly as we like in vivisection experiments we can grow them in factories for factory farming they're just mechanisms
00:08:18
that's the view which uh dominated science right up until the 20th century but there was another movement within science in the 19th century science and philosophy which uh where people tried
00:08:31
to go beyond this dualistic view a lot of people felt it's to have two completely different kinds of thing doesn't make sense there should be just one reality so one school of thought the idealists
00:08:43
said the one reality is consciousness everything is ultimately conscious the the Consciousness underlies everything matter is kind of done done mind this is the school of idealism in philosophy
00:08:55
idealism here means the Primacy of Consciousness it doesn't mean being idealistic about helping others or making the world a better place it means the the focus on Consciousness is the
00:09:08
primary indeed only reality that school of thought is undergoing Resurgence today the best known exponent of it is Bernardo castrapp a philosopher of mind
00:09:21
um but the other school the other uh school of thought in the 19th century that finally came became dominant and became the dominant philosophy of science was
00:09:32
materialism the materialist said there's no such thing as this realm of immaterial spirit doesn't do anything you can't measure it you can't weigh it you can't see it therefore it doesn't exist gods and Angels don't exist
00:09:45
they're just figments of the imagination so at one stroke God and angels disappear from this Mechanical Universe and that's all that's left is human consciousness the only thing left out of this
00:09:58
Cartesian dualism then you have the problem for materialists that they haven't been able to get rid of human consciousness they've got rid of God and angels but this human consciousness annoyingly
00:10:11
persists and this is where materialist philosophers have such a terrible job trying to explain it away as Daniel says said you know Daniel Dennis book consciousness explained Israeli an
00:10:23
attempt to explain Consciousness away as a kind of Illusion the problem is that by saying Consciousness is an illusion doesn't explain it because illusion is itself a mode of consciousness
00:10:35
and for those who say Consciousness is merely an Epi phenomenon it doesn't really do anything and Consciousness has no activity we may experience it but it doesn't do anything it's like a shadow
00:10:48
of the activity of the nervous system has no agency can't interfere with physical causality we have no free will this is standard materialist stuff um but the trouble is that it's a hard
00:11:00
problem because all attempts to explain it away in the end run into intolerable problems John sell the philosopher of Mind described the debate within the
00:11:13
philosophy of Mind Over the last 50 years as follows a philosopher advances the materialist's theory of the mind he then encounters difficulties criticisms usually take a
00:11:25
more or less technical form but in fact underlying the technical objections is a much deeper objection the theory in question is left out some essential feature of the mind and this leads to ever more frenzied attempts to stick
00:11:37
with materialist thesis well some philosophers have decided to give up on that task of trying to stick with materialist thesis and that's
00:11:49
really one of the origins of the modern versions of pan psychism the idea of those forms of Consciousness in many different levels of nature gallon strawson is one of the leaders of this
00:12:03
new pan psychus movement and um he argues that if we assume that some kind of level of mentality experience or Consciousness even in atoms and
00:12:15
electrons then the appearance of Consciousness the emergence of Consciousness in in humans is no longer something completely different emerging from utterly unconscious matter it's not
00:12:28
a difference in kind it's a difference of degree and this is why many contemporary philosophers are now going over to pan psychism another one whose book recently came out
00:12:40
as Philip Goff his book Galileo's era is a clear and um I think forceful and well-argued statement of the pan psychus position
00:12:52
and his motive is primarily to deal with the hard problem of human consciousness because if Consciousness is not just confined to human brains or animal brains then it's easier to understand
00:13:05
why we are conscious because Consciousness is no longer something special just for us it's something much more widely distributed in nature a more sophisticated and mathematical version of this is integrated
00:13:18
information theory of Julio tonnone who points out that Consciousness has an integrative capacity it doesn't work unless there's a high degree of complexity which has to be integrated
00:13:31
and Consciousness works by integration um and and so that's its defining characteristic there's a lot of technical literature on this but I'm just giving an overview
00:13:46
now as soon as we start discussing pan psychism we realize this is not a new philosophy at all as I've already mentioned this is more or less what practically everyone in ancient Greece
00:13:58
thought and also what uh in animistic forms is found in practically all traditional cultures everywhere in the world um but in European philosophy in the 17th
00:14:13
century in response to Descartes there was already a kind of pan psychist reaction two leading philosophers then were pan psyches one was Spinoza the
00:14:25
Jewish Dutch philosopher who argued that God and nature are the same that nature is like the body of God God is like the mind of Nature and so his was a pan
00:14:38
psychist even pantheist philosophy God and nature were identical it's just looked at from different points of view another and very interesting 17th century philosophy was leibniz
00:14:51
a German philosopher who argued that the whole universe was made up of monads self-organizing units and each self-organizing unit including atoms mirrored the universe consciously from
00:15:05
its own point of view said the universe was full of all sorts of individual beings with Minds that each mirrored it from their end point of view and each one Merit it differently because every monad was in a different place just like
00:15:19
everyone in this room is mirroring this room seeing this room from a different point of view from their own point of view but everyone's seeing it differently because you can't have two people in the same place at the same
00:15:32
time it's what I I the leibniz called the identity of indiscernibles um so the um he was saying the whole universe is full of Minds which are all mirroring the universe from every
00:15:45
different point of view the most interesting 20th century pan cyclist was Alfred North Whitehead a British philosopher um who was a mathematician as well he
00:16:00
wrote a fundamental book in 20th century mathematics called principia Mathematica with his student Bertrand Russell when they were both at Trinity College Cambridge and Alfred North Whitehead because he
00:16:13
was a mathematician was the first philosopher who properly understood quantum theory in the 1920s when quantum theory was just coming into being white had got it straight away most philosophers weren't mathematicians
00:16:26
couldn't follow it but Whitehead instantly realized what a radical break quantum theory was he showed that in quantum theory which
00:16:36
treats light and matter as wave-like entities the quanta A wave-like and because they are wave-like Einstein Whitehead realized that they you
00:16:51
couldn't have a wave at an instant you can't have an instantaneous wave think of waves on the sea you can't take an instantaneous slice of a wave and say Here's here's a wave at an instant a
00:17:02
wave takes time to wave in and it takes space to wave in so it's spread out in time and space you can't Define it in a particular time or place and that's the fundamental reason for the so-called
00:17:16
uncertainty principle in quantum mechanics that fundamental particles are wave-like everything in fact is wave-like um and atoms are wave patterns of
00:17:29
nucleus is a pattern of waves too and the electrons in their different orbitals resonant waves of activity so what Whitehead showed is that matter
00:17:41
is not stuff 19th century physics had treated star matters stuff like little billiard balls the atoms were like tiny billiard balls hard impenetrable stuff that just persisted he showed that
00:17:54
actually what modern quantum physics has shown is that matter is a process and it's a process because it's a wave everything is waved like even the smallest particles even the smaller
00:18:06
subatomic particles that you find in the Large Hadron Collider a wave-like um and if it's a wave and if it's a process then it takes place in time and
00:18:18
if it takes place in time it has a polarity in time the past and a future pole and what Whitehead argued was that this completely transforms our view of the nature of matter
00:18:31
his most original idea about this I think the one I find most exciting and interesting is that it gives us a way of thinking of the relation of Mind and Body in terms of time rather than space
00:18:45
we're used to the idea that the mind is the inside the body is the outside there's the external world the inner world we use these metaphors all the time there's spatial metaphors my inner life the inner World inner Consciousness
00:18:59
and indeed from a materialist point of view the brain literally is inner uni your thoughts are supposed to be nothing but the activity of your brain they're inside your head they're inside and the external world's outside and the bodies
00:19:11
outside the brain most of it um so um that we're used to that spatial metaphor it comes into ordinary language as well we're less used to the time version that
00:19:26
Whitehead was putting forward and what he was suggesting is that the mental pole the pole of the mind is the future pole the physical pole the body pole is the past Pole
00:19:39
he pointed out that even in quantum theory when you're working out the equations of quantum theory the shredding a wave equation for example is the equation that enables you to predict all the
00:19:51
possible things that an electron or other particle could do you fire off an electron from a cathode ray tube in a cathode ray tube and the shredding a wave equation describes all the possible
00:20:04
things it could do now these are possibilities they're not physical facts they're part of physics but they're not physical the it's they coexist as possibilities but as soon as
00:20:16
the electron interacts with something a measuring apparatus or with another atom um then all these possibilities collapse down until you've got one measurable
00:20:27
fact which is now a physical fact it's now the body as it were the body of that electron has a definite place you can measure it in a particular place and it's sometimes called the collapse of the wave function
00:20:41
well what Whitehead uh showed really was that this is a general principle about the way the minds work our own minds are arenas of possibility our own conscious Minds um
00:20:53
our Consciousness is is an arena where we hold together a range of possibilities if we don't have many possibilities we don't need to be conscious of it and most of our habits don't involve considering possibility we
00:21:07
just do it the same way we've done it before habits are generally unconscious they're mental but they're unconscious conscious minds are concerned with possibilities and choosing among them
00:21:19
so for example all of us chose to come here today we could have done all sorts of other things this afternoon but we chose to come here and among the many possibilities we chose this one and we
00:21:33
made it happen it's realized it's now a physical fact we can be measured photographed weighed in this room it's a physical fact we're here and our mind's now open to new possibilities so it's a
00:21:46
constant interplay of possibility becoming physical but as soon as it's physical it's in the past and then new possibilities open in the future so this is Whitehead's conception of her
00:21:58
mind's work and it gives us a way of thinking of Consciousness as something that deals with possibility it's where I find a very helpful way of thinking about the nature of Consciousness and since possibilities aren't physical
00:22:11
they're virtual they're virtual futures um among which we choose it helps us to understand that Consciousness is part of nature but it's not something
00:22:27
you can physically measure any more than you can measure all the possibilities that an electron has you can only measure the physical facts when the wave function collapses and you can say well these the the the shredding a wave
00:22:39
equation just gives us the probability distribution of what might happen not what will happen so um Whitehead was also a very important part
00:22:51
of the the birth of the holistic or organismic philosophy of nature the old mechanistic materialist view was that we should explain everything in terms of the smallest things the atoms
00:23:04
are the ultimate physical reality and therefore reducing chemistry to atoms is the way chemistry should go reducing life to molecules is the way biology should go reduce it to the smallest
00:23:15
things in living organisms molecules so it's a matter of reducing to the smallest because smallest is best and that's why molecular biology has an enormously High status within biology
00:23:28
because it's dealing with the smallest bits of living organisms genes proteins Etc but what Whitehead pointed out is that um atoms are not the ultimate particles
00:23:41
atoms themselves are structures of activity with a nucleus and electron orbitals and they're all processes atoms are processes molecules are processes and that molecules are like
00:23:54
they're like organisms an atom is like a microscopic organism a molecule is an organism composed of atoms which a whole have a wholeness that goes beyond the sum of the parts
00:24:06
um in the same way in organisms a cell is self-organizing it has its own membrane its own limits its own structure and activity but cells can be organized in tissues where there's a wholeness that's more than some of the
00:24:20
parts they're in organs in organisms in in societies of organisms like flocks of birds or schools of fish in ecosystems in planets and planets within solar
00:24:32
systems which again have a wholeness that's more than some of the parts and solar systems within galaxies so we have organisms at all levels of complexity and you can't reduce them all
00:24:44
to Ultimate particles and the bottom dropped out of the atom long ago and and helped to explain everything in terms of the ultimate particle is no longer the way science works and it never really
00:24:56
has worked that way you don't try and explain the facts of Sociology or the facts of physiology in terms of hadrons or electrons and so on and you explain them
00:25:09
in terms of physiological processes science in in effect although not in theory is actually holistic you study things that they're in level well
00:25:21
if we take this View then we see that this holistic view of nature suggests that self-organizing systems
00:25:34
have a kind of mind or Consciousness uh or an organizing capacity of their own purposes their own goals which in modern Dynamics are called attractors
00:25:45
um and it also shows certain kinds of things are not self-organizing and are not likely to be conscious an atom a molecule a cell a tissue an organ a
00:25:58
flock of birds a Galaxy a solar system have a wholeness that's more than some of the parts and may have some kind of mind dealing with their possible future actions but things which are mere
00:26:11
Composites are not likely to be conscious in this way this is also a point that tanoni makes in his integrated information Theory a table a chair a computer a car
00:26:24
um a rock that's just rolled down a mansion and not self-organizing holes if they were we wouldn't need factories we'd grow them on farms instead of making them in factories by putting
00:26:37
components together so the very worst possible model for nature is a machine because a machine is made out of parts that are put together in factories according to a design an
00:26:50
intelligent design which is outside the machinery and it and fulfilling human purposes which are also outside the Machinery organisms have their own organizing capacity within them they're
00:27:02
self-organizing their own purposes and so this kind of pan psychism is not saying as some people assume when people are sneeringly dismissive of pansychism they
00:27:15
say oh you're saying there's chairs conscious haha you know you get that kind of just sneering dismissal many of you will have encountered there do you know well this rock is this they always
00:27:25
pick cups rocks socks chairs computers as examples and which no one is claiming no serious pan psychics is claiming that these are conscious they may be made of
00:27:38
conscious Crystal or with a low level of Consciousness or atoms but the sock or the chair or the computer is not a conscious being and and self-organizing
00:27:50
systems have their own ends or goals um and again you get the contrast with if you if you're trying to get somewhere you get into a car the car doesn't have any goal of its own where it wants to go
00:28:01
it's go wherever you want it to if you get onto a horse the horse may well have its own idea about where it wants to go it's happened to me in Ireland once I rented a horse with some friends and two
00:28:14
I'm not an expert horse rider I found myself going down paths that I didn't think were part of the standard route until I found myself arriving at a stable the horse had simply gone home it didn't want to go on this long ride with
00:28:27
me on its back um so um this this gives us a view of how Minds might work and it also shows that if if we're talking about plants our
00:28:40
plants conscious I mean there's a whole conference every year in London called plant Consciousness now there are whole books on plant intelligence and the secret life of trees and so on um If plants are conscious they're
00:28:53
likely to be conscious about things where they have a choice they're not likely to be conscious about things which are just purely habitual same as us we're not conscious of most of our
00:29:05
mental activity most of our lives are we're creatures of habit most of our mental life is Habitual um we only use our Consciousness when we're
00:29:17
thinking about possible actions we have to choose between now I think the interesting point about this pan psychist argument in the present uh climate is that most pan
00:29:30
psychists who are around today are strawsen golf tononi Koch the neuroscientist who used to work with Francis Crick who used to be an absolutely Hardline reductionist materialist has recently gone over to
00:29:43
pen psychism as well this is a large-scale movement within philosophy and Neuroscience um but the main reason they they've adopted
00:29:54
pan psychism is to try and explain the hard problem human consciousness um so they talk about electrons atoms molecules maybe cells and tissues but
00:30:06
they stop when you get to human beings I think this debate is most interesting when you carry on you know flocks of animals or social groups ecosystems the whole planet I mean we already have a
00:30:20
holistic view of Gaia the planet in the Gaia hypothesis which is telling us that the entire planet is like a living organism um and then if we carry on to the solar
00:30:32
system and particularly to the Sun um I'm particularly interested in this question of is this unconscious and as soon as you raise that question you realize that you're breaking a taboo
00:30:44
you know as a modern educated person you're not meant to ask that question it's you're meant to sneer if somebody says is the sun conscious you're meant to dismiss it as absurd or ridiculous or
00:30:57
childish and the reason it's so easily dismissed as childish and ridiculous is that practically All Humans except us have taken it for granted so the the idea is we're better than them because we're
00:31:10
smarter more educated more scientific and they're all wallowing in ridiculous superstitions uh also children think the sun's conscious that's why they draw it with a smiley face again proof that it's
00:31:23
a childish Superstition um well in in most cultures people think the sun is conscious and usually think of it as a God or a goddess the Greeks thought of the Sun as a god
00:31:37
Apollo the Romans as a god Soul um but some people think it is the Hindus Syria but some people think of the Sun as a goddess the Japanese for
00:31:49
the Japanese the sun is a very important goddess in their whole cosmology in the in the cosmologies of Northern Europe the sun was a goddess and that's why um in German and in the Germanic
00:32:03
language the sun is feminine dishonor and the Moon is masculine der Mont whereas in the romance languages it's the other way around Le Soleil in French is masculine son and La Lun the Moon is
00:32:16
feminine so sometimes people think oh the moon's feminine the sun's masculine Etc it does it depends on the Mythic system you're working with and um I personally think that this view of
00:32:29
the Sun and similar aspects of the natural world is one reason for the evolution of the English language as we know it in parentheses you know think about the evolution of our language
00:32:42
um the people living in England at the time of the Norman Conquest were speaking Germanic languages Anglo-Saxon and other Germanic languages in which the sun is feminine
00:32:54
the Norman Invaders spoke French and the court language in England for several centuries was French and the English language as we know it is a kind of hybrid of French and German or French type and German type languages
00:33:08
and what did the our ancestors do when they were trying to deal with the gender of the sun you know one Lord say it's feminine the other Lord says masculine the moon again the opposite way around
00:33:20
how do you deal with that well what they did do was expanded the neuter gender which in Germanic languages there's masculine feminine and neuter expanded neuter to include practically everything except people and ships
00:33:34
um so um and and so we neutralized the entire world in English um and I think that this these conflicting mythologies and genders are actually probably one of the main
00:33:47
reasons why that happened but that's an aside my point here is that traditional cultures have thought of the Sun as alive and conscious and they actually um in India I lived in India for seven
00:34:00
years and in India Hindus for example take it for granted that the sun is a conscious being and they relate to it there's a yoga exercise that many of you might do I've done it every morning for
00:34:14
more than 40 years the Surya namaskar the salutation to the sun which you do facing the sun in the morning greeting the Sun and and this isn't just for physical health and to stretch and stuff
00:34:27
I mean yoga's been secularized in the west but in India it's about actually prostrating to the sun which is the great power of the sun is that on which all our lives depend
00:34:39
and the most well perhaps the most fundamental Mantra in Hinduism the Gayatri Mantra it's a little bit like the Lord's Prayer in Christianity is that something that is very very widely
00:34:51
known as a fundamental Mantra is a prayer to the Glorious Splendor of the sun to illuminate our meditation the Divine and glorious Splendor of the Sun
00:35:03
um so devout Hindus every morning make this prayer to the son asking for its blessings on our lives implicitly uh there's a thinking of the Sun as a conscious being that can respond to
00:35:17
prayers no of course as soon as you look in the physics textbook then you realize that's not the way physics is it's just a kind of giant hydrogen bomb with physical processes going on that's totally unconscious
00:35:29
but it's not as if scientists have ever proved the Sun or the other stars are unconscious they've just assumed it because Descartes said so in the 17th century defined all matter as
00:35:41
unconscious by definition not by proof empirical inquiry rational discussion a simple Prejudice and taboo has become established on these questions where they're not valid topics for discussion
00:35:55
except perhaps at the weekend University and in most educational institutions this would not be something you could talk about um so I think that the um the question
00:36:09
it's a an open question is the sun conscious and um then if we think about that a little bit more well the first we'd have to recognize straight away that if the sun's conscious then all the other stars
00:36:22
are probably conscious too so you can't just confine it to the sun because it's the nearest one to us this must be a general argument then was the question of his conscious then what's the interface between its
00:36:34
mind and its body uh well what's the interface between our brains and our minds our bodies and our minds most people would think that that interface is to do with the electrical patterns of
00:36:46
activity in the brain that that's what it relates to our Consciousness you know eegu algorithms theta waves Delta rhythms and so on depend on your State of Consciousness
00:36:58
that the somehow the electrical activity of the brain is what underlies mental activity this is what electrochemical activity because of course there are neurotransmitters but
00:37:11
so but it's principally the electrical activity that people are interested in and neurophysiologists measure and neuroscientists measure this activity through all sorts of electrical devices
00:37:24
not just eegs electroencephalographs um well does the Sun have electrical activity well yes it does the sun has immensely complex patterns of electrical activity it has its whole surfaces
00:37:38
covered with granulations millions of them each side of the sun has at least a million of these granulations which are like convection cells which are made of electrically charged plasma they set up electrical currents through their
00:37:52
movements then you have annual you have 11-year cycles of solar activity the Sunspot Cycle where you get more and more sunspots and each Sunspot is dark because there's such intense magnetic
00:38:05
fields coming out of it that they form huge loops with other sunspots and they sort of push everything else aside and those Sunspot those magnetic fields interact and underlie the heat in the
00:38:18
Solar carono the corona of the sun is about 5 million degrees Centigrade the Photosphere the bit you see when you look at the sun is only about 5000 degrees Centigrade so there's a lot of
00:38:31
heat generated and it's thought to happen through the interaction of these magnetic fields and this is completely unpredictable the behavior of the sun that's why NASA the American
00:38:44
Space Administration issues weather forecasts solar weather forecasts because the activity of the sun is very variable even these 11-year Cycles are rather variable every 11 years around
00:38:58
the middle of the Sunspot Cycle the sun's magnetic polarity reverses says north magnetic pole becomes the South Pole so the entire polarity of the sun flips but sometimes it doesn't flip that much although these Cycles are rather
00:39:12
weak recently we've had a very weak solar cycle um so the sun is full of immensely active highly differentiated electrical activity and magnetic
00:39:24
activity and this is instantly integrated through the electrical and magnetic fields of the sun which permeate the entire solar system the solar wind comes out of the sun and
00:39:36
it reaches right to the end the whole the whole solar system has a kind of membrane around it called the heliopause where the solar wind encounters the galactic wind of charged particles moving through the Galaxy and where they
00:39:50
interact it forms a kind of membrane around the solar system we're all enclosed in a kind of bubble and within that bubble everything's dominated by the sun's electromagnetic field its
00:40:02
radiation and the solar wind of charged particles that are coming out of the sun all the time sometimes there are more than others there are coronal mass ejections when huge billions of tons of matter pushed
00:40:14
out of the sun there's also a set of flowers which send out intense pulses of charged particles if one of them hits the Earth it takes out our power
00:40:26
transmission systems and if a really powerful one hit the earth it would our whole civilization because uh a National Grid and other electrical transmission systems act as Aerials for
00:40:38
this and would absorb this energy and would blow out all the Transformers take months to make enough new Transformers to restore the National Grid um so the sun can have enormous effects
00:40:51
here on Earth it's 11 year Cycles affect the climate the weather um and uh it could if it shows take out civilization as we know it um at any time um
00:41:04
so the sun may have all sorts of possibilities in its mind if it's conscious and those possibilities would include deciding where and when to fire off solar flares or coronal mass ejections
00:41:17
perhaps we're not we haven't had any recently or perhaps have been relatively few and they mostly missed the Earth but if one hits It's assumed to be totally random within regular science but
00:41:30
um you know Hindus who do their daily prayer with the Gayatri Mantra think that the sun's being kind to us because they're asking it to be kind to us and you know we may scorn what they're doing say oh ridiculous Superstition but it
00:41:42
may be we're all benefiting from it without realizing it and certainly the average physics department isn't going to do much in terms of making the sun feel good about us
00:41:54
treating it as some totally inanimate object that's nothing but the realization of a few equations in physics textbooks um I mean but even physicists of course
00:42:06
recognize that the sun is highly Dynamic and there's still a great deal we don't know about it so if the Sun is a conscious being then what about the entire galaxy that contains the solar systems within
00:42:19
it like cells within a body the entire galaxy may have a galactic mind and it may communicate with other galaxies the Sun May communicate with other stars primarily as Consciousness is I suppose
00:42:32
directed towards its body of the solar system and the sun itself but it's also got a peer group other stars within in the galaxy um and we know very little about
00:42:44
Galactic thoughts or Galactic thought transference it's unlikely I think if galaxies do communicate with each other that they do it just by electromagnetic radiation because some of them are a
00:42:56
thousand light years apart which means it would take a thousand years for a light impulse or electromagnetic magnetic impulses go from one galaxy to another
00:43:08
um and and then another thousand years now well the hundreds of thousands they're a billion years some of them are a billion years apart take a billion years to send a message to a distant Galaxy in another billion years to get a reply even if it was by return of post
00:43:21
so two billion years is a long time so if they do communicate then I think there must be some kind of Intergalactic telepathy but obviously this is getting into a realm of speculation that um is
00:43:34
is Way Way Beyond anything we actually know um but um and then if all the galaxies have a kind of Consciousness then what about the entire universe
00:43:47
the entire universe may have a mind a mind of the universe which is exactly what Plato was suggesting in the time years um the entire Cosmos may have a mind
00:43:59
and how would its sensory system work well there are some neuroscientists who think that the interface between the mind and the brain is not just electromagnetic fields
00:44:11
acting as an interface but they think that the electromagnetic fields in the brain actually are conscious that that is the basis of consciousness John Joe McFadden for example has
00:44:23
proposed that the electromagnetic field Theory Of Consciousness and Todd Murphy a Canadian neuroscientist has proposed the magnetic field Theory Of Consciousness that these fields are the
00:44:35
the basis of Consciousness well if we take those theories seriously and apply them to the whole universe the universe is pervaded by the gravitational field and the electromagnetic field and therefore a mind could interact with
00:44:50
that would know everything in the universe because it would be the basis of where where everything is and how everything is its activity there'd be an instant method for omniscience throughout the Universe
00:45:04
then um I know where I'm piling speculation on speculation but um you know I just want to deal with a a further point that if we say the whole universe is conscious then are we saying
00:45:17
that's the ultimate limit of Consciousness if we are it's a form of pantheism like Spinoza um but all traditional religions have said that the universe is alive and
00:45:29
conscious in some way but there's a Consciousness that transcends even the universe that there's a mind beyond the universe as well as the Mind within the universe rather like our own minds are
00:45:43
concerned with the welfare of our bodies and our social behavior and so on but they can also transcend all our immediate concerns we can think about as we are doing now the nature of the
00:45:55
universe the nature of other Minds in the universe things that have nothing to do with catching the tube home this evening or what we have for dinner our immediate preoccupations but we're but
00:46:07
with the the the fact that our minds can transcend totally the immediate concerns of our bodies and our social lives and so there are the idea has always been there's a mind that
00:46:19
goes beyond the universe so when we then come to the question of what might such an ultimate mind be then we have to turn not philosophy of mind which is on the whole concerned with
00:46:33
much smaller problems but to theology because theology is the subject which deals with the nature of ultimate consciousness and there's a surprising um surprisingly sort of lively activity
00:46:46
going on in theology at the moment partly because Different World Systems like the Hindu world view the Buddhist world view the Sufi worldview the Christian world view
00:46:59
are now accessible to Scholars and in a very brilliant book by a theologian called David Bentley Hart h-a-r-t an American Theologian a recent book it's
00:47:11
called the experience of God being Consciousness Bliss and what he does is takes the uh this threefold analysis of ultimate Consciousness from
00:47:22
the Hindu system sat chit Ananda being Consciousness Bliss is how the Hindus think the ultimate mind works the ground of being is conscious there's a
00:47:35
conscious ground on which everything rests and its being and its Consciousness that's its primary quality is sapped his conscious being in the present or in all time as well
00:47:47
um chipped is names is consciousness itself what can be known names and forms as the Indians say Nama Rupa names and forms the whole universe is made up of forms
00:48:00
plants animals planets Stars cells atoms molecules these are all forms forms of organization and we have names for them which are forms in our minds which enable us to relate to what's out there
00:48:14
in the world so namaroopa is names and forms these are within the conscious mind they're not the conscious mind itself that's like the basis on which through which
00:48:27
these are known think of a screen of your computer the screen's there whatever you look at on the computer but there's a basis for everything you see there you can see all sorts of different things read all sorts of different texts but there's something there
00:48:40
underlying them all and the idea is there's a conscious mind the knower which is that which knows everything that can be known there's the contents of Consciousness are not the same as Consciousness itself
00:48:53
then there's a dynamical principle which is the principle of energy breath movement change which is part of Consciousness as well and being in the flow of that change is joyful that's why
00:49:08
Ananda satchit Ananda Joy is part of the ultimate Divine mind um so we have a very similar model in the Christian Holy Trinity the official
00:49:21
definition of God in the Creeds the various Christian Creeds are really statements of this threefold nature of God God the father is the ground of being in the Old Testament when God announced himself to Moses he says I am
00:49:35
that I am conscious being in the present um called the sun is the logos the principle of name and form through which all things were made um it's the like the platonic realm of
00:49:49
forms or ideas or archetypes of all things in nature and the spirit is the breath the principle of energy change and movement the principle metaphor
00:50:01
in the in the Holy Trinity is speaking I mean all these things are metaphorical obviously the ultimate mind is beyond our conception but we can have metaphors which help us to think about it
00:50:15
and they are the the the in in many Traditions the Hindu one as well speaking has a particular role as a metaphor when I'm speaking now um there is on one hand there's me the
00:50:28
speaker uh and there's two other things involved as the speaker there's The Words which have structure form meaning connection Etc patterns definable patterns they're
00:50:40
distinct from each other there's lots of different possible words um and there's also the breath on which the words are carried if I weren't breathing out as I spoke you wouldn't hear anything if I don't breathe well I think
00:50:54
thoughts or have words in my mind they're just silent in my mind if I have just breath without words there's a flow of air but there's no particular structure or pattern so you
00:51:09
have to have both the flow of energy and the form which gives structure meaning and pattern and the ground of both and that's the basic model um the in in the Christian tradition and
00:51:23
in the Hindu tradition and there's a very similar model in the Islamic tradition as David Bentley heart chose there are parallels in the Buddhist cosmology as well um and so what this is this is a basic
00:51:36
archetype of Consciousness that underlies all things is reflected in the whole universe the whole universe has forms and it has energy forms are given
00:51:48
by fields and Fields in the standard science governed by the laws of nature in my view their habits that have a kind of memory um so the the
00:52:01
um everything in nature has both a combination of form and energy and electron an atom has form given by the principles of quantum field Theory and energy if it hadn't got the energy
00:52:13
it wouldn't exist if it hadn't got the form it wouldn't be a definable entity it would even light which is undifferentiated energies and differentiated as it can get still has wavelength it still has some formal
00:52:26
pattern where light has different wavelengths um so everything has formed and energy and a conscious being underlying it and that same model would apply to our own
00:52:40
Consciousness we have of course we need energy we have eat food we have electrical energy in our nerves we we have formed that our bodies take up during embryology there are patterns of activity in our brains there's energy
00:52:53
flowing through our brains and some of these patterns of energy and some of these forms are become conscious and our conscious Minds are full of all sorts of forms names and
00:53:07
forms we can form pictures in our dreams we can see images of things that aren't actually in front of us there's always a dynamical principle where it's moving in in our dreams
00:53:19
um so I think that the when we ask the question is the universe conscious then it's possible to say yes it could be conscious and what's more its
00:53:32
Consciousness could tell us something about the ultimate source of all Consciousness everything within the universe could be like fractal versions of this Universal Consciousness with a
00:53:43
Unity of the given of whatever system it is the ground of being of that system together with the forms and the energy that make it up and we can see this as underlying our
00:53:56
own mental activity now of course this leads to all sorts of detailed changes in our brains which neuroscientists can study but we're never going to understand the nature of Consciousness just through
00:54:08
studying brains because then we get back to the hard problem you can't just explain Consciousness in terms of brain activity you can find out ever more details about the activity you can
00:54:20
believe as some materialists believe that if we go on studying brains long enough sooner or later the answer to Consciousness will just appear but I think on philosophical grounds that's simply not going to happen
00:54:32
um and what we're in at the moment is this fascinating uh transition point between mechanistic materialism which works very well for physics it works very well for making machines iPhones
00:54:45
televisions jet airplanes and so forth but it works very badly for explaining consciousness and spiritual experiences which many people access through a whole range of
00:54:59
spiritual practices and there's a Revival of spiritual practices today I discussed seven in each of my two recent books science and spiritual practices and ways to go beyond and why they work
00:55:12
these spiritual practices are ways in which we can actually get into a closer direct experience with these forms of Consciousness beyond the human level meditation um are very practiced by many people as
00:55:25
a way of de-stressing after a busy day or counteracting anxiety and depression it's now practiced as a secular at well-being type exercise in the cultures
00:55:38
from which it comes contemplative Christianity monks and nuns in in monasteries Hindu meditators Buddhist meditators Sufi meditators the people
00:55:49
who've done it traditionally in a religious context have done it not just so they're less stressed and they can cope with the stresses of Modern Life they've done it because they think that by getting to the very ground of
00:56:01
Consciousness itself because he when you get past the ruminations you cease to identify with the constant flow of thoughts that going through your mind you can reach states where you're in the state of awareness
00:56:15
just conscious of being that that conscious being puts us in touch with the ground of conscious being of all things the Hindus like to use an analogy they
00:56:27
say think of lots of buckets of water at night with the moon and you can look in each bucket of water you'll see a reflection of the Moon it looks as if there's hundreds of moons but actually there's just one Moon reflected in all
00:56:41
these buckets and there's one ultimate mind reflected in all conscious beings in the universe in each one of us in every conscious animal and every conscious being of every kind Stars galaxies in the entire universe
00:56:55
um so that meditation is a practice for getting to the ground of being so other spiritual practices like music dancing and sports which I think is the most common spiritual practice in the
00:57:08
modern world that takes people into Altered States Of Consciousness um especially being in the present it works quicker and more effectively than meditation you can't when you're 50 feet up at rock face start worrying and
00:57:21
ruminating about whether you've paid the gas bill and or not if you're in the middle of a football game and someone's passing you the ball the crowds are cheering you can't think about some remark your girlfriend made that pissed you off the day before you you are
00:57:34
totally in the present and sports are the principle where I think in the modern world in which people come completely into the present meditation is a slower process but Sports and moving spiritual practices like sacred
00:57:48
dance music but I think connects us from the dimension of spirit the moving principle of Ultimate Reality and I think aesthetic enjoyment enjoying the beauty of flowers a beautiful
00:58:01
architecture of art is more connecting with logos or beauty aspect of spiritual reality so these spiritual practices connect us in different ways with different aspects
00:58:13
of this ultimate consciousness um I personally think that this is a better way of experiencing it so I think of it myself I mean I've spent years as a card
00:58:25
carrying materialist an atheist so I'm very familiar with that world view but if you want to stick to a materialist world view and dismiss all these experiences as make-believe then
00:58:37
what you have to do is dismiss your own experience of Consciousness especially if you've had mystical experiences or senses of connection through spiritual practices including psychedelics which
00:58:49
can provide spiritual openings you you have if you're going to dismiss your own experience in favor of a theory the theory that is nothing but the activity of the brain that Consciousness isn't really doing anything you're
00:59:02
putting a theory ahead of your own experience but since Consciousness is experience and since we're meant to be empirical if we're going to be scientific empiricism is experience
00:59:14
that's what it means in Greek empirical means experiential to do with experience you have to make a personal choice so each one of us does whether to put our own personal experience of these things
00:59:27
to take pay more attention to that especially when it gives us a sense of forms of Consciousness beyond our own or keep going back to the materialist Theory it's nothing but the brain the material Theory as I say is brilliant
00:59:40
for machines it's not brilliant for understanding in Consciousness it leads to the hard problem and so it's not really the best theory in the world for explaining Consciousness it's probably the worst theory in the world for explaining it otherwise it wouldn't lead
00:59:54
to hard problem but this is a question that lies before everybody today um because we're on a cusp I think between a paradigm shift from mechanistic materialism which has dominated academic life in our society
01:00:07
for decades to a more uh Rich view of nature as a live a more pan psychist or animist view of the world and what a view of the world in which Consciousness is more than just an activity in human
01:00:22
brains and it's an activity at greater forms of Consciousness we can actually access through our own direct experience the choice is up to each one of us and we'll have to use both our rational
01:00:35
minds and our experience in trying to decide between these are different possibilities thank you we're now going to have a short break five to seven minutes is what Neil said
01:00:52
um and then we'll have a session when there can be questions answers comments Rupa hello um I've got I don't know where to start really
01:01:04
um my I guess firstly an observation and that is that I thought that you were going to sort of posit um posit your theory of Consciousness
01:01:16
around morphic resonance around the sense that Consciousness is out there in the universe and that in a sense if I understand it correctly you believe that you could say our brain's a bit more like a kind of radio they sort of pick
01:01:29
up a slice of that Consciousness which is um which is unique to us so I was kind of rather looking forward to you um explaining that and explaining to us where the evidence where your evidence
01:01:42
for that is and in particular why you haven't published why there isn't a published paper with this idea which has been peer-reviewed you know by scientists because let's be really honest and I'm really not trying to be
01:01:55
unkind here I'm trying to be truthful um you have been your ideas have been very shunned in the scientific community and I sort of wondered what what your reaction to that was and my second
01:02:07
question is really to ask you about your personal beliefs some my understanding is that you're a Christian and I completely respect and understand the human need for spirituality I'm not I'm not just a
01:02:20
materialist but I'm wondering how you have come to the Christian way of explaining the world and why that would be correct and not for example the Islamic or the
01:02:32
Jewish or or an atheist or Hindu or any other so there's two two things really why didn't you talk about your actual central idea and secondly what are your personal beliefs gosh well these are
01:02:45
both huge questions but but I think hugely relevant all right yes they are they're very relevant well first of all I had intended to talk about morphic resonance in this talk
01:02:57
um but I always speak from notes and um there just wasn't time if I'd brought it up at all I would have had to explain the whole Theory which would take at least 20 minutes and since the title I was working on is is the universe
01:03:11
conscious rather than does morphic resonance exist that's what I was speaking about um I mean I didn't make up the title Neil the vice Chancellor of the weekend University gave me this title and you
01:03:24
know I wanted to talk about what the advertised title was as it so happens I am very interested in this question of is the sun conscious and in fact right now I'm writing a paper called is this
01:03:37
unconscious for the Journal of Consciousness studies a peer-reviewed journal um I've written a lot of papers in peer-reviewed journals I mean they're including ones on morphic resonance on
01:03:50
my website there's dozens of I mean there's 90 papers all together um probably six or seven on morphic resonance quite a lot on telepathy quite a number on other aspects of the
01:04:02
extended mind so I do publish in peer-reviewed journals um the um it I I mean I do it out of a sense of Duty and so I don't do it because anyone
01:04:15
actually reads the papers and hardly anyone I know has read any of my papers in peer-reviewed journals um and so it's more effective way of getting ideas across as books and talks
01:04:29
but they're all there for anyone who's interested including empirical studies on morphic resonance and many empirical studies on the nature of the Mind particularly the extended mind I haven't
01:04:41
talked today at all about all my work on telepathy the extended mind premonitions animal unexplained powers of animals homing pigeons I mean I have to focus on something I mean the entire universe
01:04:54
seemed to be enough for one afternoon and hmm let's enter so um in in terms of my own path I went
01:05:07
through as a by the age of about 14 I became a fairly militant atheist a pain in as Thorn In the Flesh of the chaplain of my church of England school
01:05:20
um and I I was a sort of atheistic materialist for quite a long time you know until my 30s then I went to India I traveled through
01:05:31
India in 1968 I was working in Malaysia for a year and I later in 1974 went to live in India where I had a job there in agricultural Research Institute and traveling in Asia opened my mind to
01:05:46
all sorts of other ways of looking at reality I met perfectly rational Indians who thought in terms of the consciousness of sachet and under uh you know meditation and the what's going on
01:05:57
in that so I became very influenced by the Hindu tradition um I had Hindu gurus I did yoga I did meditation then I had a Sufi teacher I got interested in Sufism I had some
01:06:10
Muslim friends in Hyderabad I suppose which is where I lived I spoke Urdu and I was drawn into a kind of Sufi World which I found very attractive and interesting and for a while I had Sufi practices and then I thought well you know there's
01:06:23
no way I'm going to become a Sufi a Sufi means you've got to become a Muslim first you know and and I didn't particularly want to have to fasten Ramadan and buy into the whole Quran and I I mean I had been circumcised so that
01:06:35
one of the main obstacles for people the more painful aspect was it was all right so but as I did seriously consider it for about 10 minutes and and then I thought well I can't really be a Hindu
01:06:47
because you know Hindus isn't so much about the land of India the temples of India the traditions of India um and and I went to see a Hindu Guru and asked his advice on the spiritual
01:06:59
path he said well you come from a Christian background you should try being a good Christian all past lead to God and you know that's the one that's most natural for you your own tradition so I thought well I hadn't thought of
01:07:11
that I thought okay I so I I tried it out and it worked really well for me and then I met a wonderful Christian teacher father B Griffis who lived in at ashram a Benedictine monk in an ashram in South
01:07:25
India where I spent some time I wrote my first book in his ashram and when I came back to England I found reconnecting with the Christian tradition was really helpful the great Cathedrals the holy places the churches
01:07:38
the festivals uh fasting in Lent all these things made sense to me um but I'm not an evangelizing Christian and sense I think everyone should be a Christian I don't think they should um I've no I think Muslims and Hindus
01:07:52
and Buddhists are fine the way they are and if I'd been born in India I'm sure I'd be a Hindu or a Muslim or whatever but I'm English I was born in England this is the tradition of my ancestors
01:08:04
and anamorphic resonance principles it's the one that works most naturally and easily for me and I totally respect that it works for you and it gives you comfort and it makes your life better I
01:08:16
understand the world as being true well this is another big question um I think that the doctrine of the nature of ultimate Consciousness the Holy
01:08:32
Trinity which is the Christian view of God as I spoke about earlier I think is a very good model it's a metaphorical model of Ultimate Reality Hindus and other religions have rather similar ones
01:08:44
a trinitarian understanding I think is probably the best model we can have whether you call it Snapchat and under or father Son and Holy Spirit so I think in that sense it's true in the sense
01:08:56
that it's a model about Ultimate Reality is probably as good as we can get obviously by definition an ultimate conscious mind that Embraces the entire universe with billions of galaxies is
01:09:07
likely to be beyond the grasp of our own very limited Minds that have evolved through millions of years of sort of hunting and Gathering and hundreds of thousands of years of making Stone axes and things
01:09:20
um so I think it's likely to be a limited understanding um I think other aspects of the Christian story I think religion is more about practice than truth frankly I mean
01:09:32
I pray I meditate I go to church services I go on pilgrimages I sing these are all spiritual practices that give a sense of connection
01:09:44
um and in that sense they're true now whether or not Jesus was actually born on December the 25th in A.D naught I it doesn't bother me much I'm not very interested in those kinds of details I'm
01:09:58
more interested in the bigger picture and the practices so I don't think everything in the Bible is literally true and actually most serious Christians throughout time have never thought that it's only American
01:10:10
fundamentalists who think that so so you know I don't think materialism's true um and I think I I think it's actually false and um I think that there are
01:10:23
various religious approaches which are more appropriate for some people than others so I'm not saying there is one truth and this is it thank you all right next question
01:10:42
uh thank you very much um my question is if uh natural laws the laws of physics laws of nature are best understood as most habits than laws
01:10:55
and if natural systems tend to be shaped by these natural habits or laws um reflecting on the points that you made in this talk um that natural systems only tend to be
01:11:08
conscious of that which they can choose between and the habits themselves don't tend to be conscious my question is um does Choice itself necessarily lie outside the laws of nature if they're
01:11:21
habitual and if so what might that tell us about the future of the science of choice well I think that all habits tend to become habitual I mean our own habits they become unconscious you know when
01:11:35
you're learning to ride your bicycle you're thinking about where to turn the handlebars and which pedal to put your feet on and that sort of thing and but once you know how to learn to once you know how to ride a bicycle you don't
01:11:47
think about it it just happens automatically thinking about it should probably be a disadvantage you can cycle along thinking about something else or having a conversation or listening to music or whatever
01:11:59
um so I think that the the habits of nature are largely unconscious but I think when any uh organ self-organizing system has
01:12:11
to make a choice um then there may be an element of Consciousness within it um but then it may go back into unconsciousness and Mayors it will almost go to sleep you know after all we
01:12:24
go to sleep we're conscious beings we're not conscious all the time we go to sleep and when we're asleep unconscious patterns of activity happen in our bodies you know liver grows our wounds
01:12:36
keep healing all sorts our brains keep active all sorts of things happen unconsciously um I'm not supposing anything in nature is necessarily more conscious than we
01:12:48
are and I I just think most where the where the Consciousness would come in as especially is when the habits are blocked it we go on with our normal habits unless we're prevented
01:13:00
um if you have an accident and you suddenly can't walk anymore you can't see anymore you have to develop new ways of living in the world and most things mutations in biology and many
01:13:12
environmental changes that organisms undergo a deleterious they block their habits they make it harder for them to survive with the old habits so they have to develop new ones then you have the
01:13:25
exploration of possibilities of new possibilities and creativity I think in The evolutionary sense and in every sense really comes about through considering new possibilities when which
01:13:38
you have to do if the old habits are blocked if the old habits are not blocked you just go on with them and I think that the whole of the evolution of the universe is one where there's creativity at every level I mean the
01:13:50
atoms molecules crystals none of these were there at the moment of the Big Bang all the everything in nature has come about through creativity which settles down into habits um
01:14:02
you know in carbon atoms get into the habits of being in certain kinds of molecules you know methane and hemoglobin and so on the glucose cellulose um but occasionally well quite often
01:14:16
chemists invent completely new organic chemicals and they'd find themselves in a completely new chemical and a new kind of Crystal these new habits are coming into being um you know hundreds of them every year
01:14:29
um so I think that the the the the Consciousness is coming into play especially when habits are blocked and is particularly important when there's a need for creativity which there is at all levels of nature throughout the
01:14:42
evolutionary process hello there um I was just wondering um your opinion as to why there's such a pushback um in Academia
01:14:55
um as to the idea of animism and why um yeah why in Western um why the Western science Community science Community um is so reluctant to unify or think of
01:15:06
spirit and matter as different aspects of the same thing well I think it's it's a historical result of of the way science has developed in Europe
01:15:21
um you know in in the 17th century um when the Sciences were getting going um there was there was this terrible Wars of religion the 30 years war between Protestants and
01:15:33
Catholics and a lot of people who are in favor of science then said that science was the third way it involved a direct insight into God's mind these were not atheists they were Christian or Jewish
01:15:45
but they they they thought that science that God was a mathematician who'd made the world machine that God's mind was mathematical mind and that by discovering the laws of nature like Newton's law of gravitation humans were
01:15:59
getting in direct access to the Divine mind that science was a spiritual Pursuit and moreover it was one that was better than a priests and and ministers and things quarreling with each other
01:16:12
about interpretations of the scriptures so um science gained enormous Prestige and by the end of the 18th century it became the standard view of Enlightenment intellectuals The Way Forward is through science and reason
01:16:25
and human progress and then technology and religion was seen as an obstacle and and many of these uh Pro like in the French Revolution which was based on
01:16:37
science and reason the cult of in fact in 1793 during the reign of terror they pronounced the cult of reason the state religion the the cathedrals and churches were closed the monasteries devolved
01:16:50
dissolved many priests were guillotined and um they they proclaimed the count of reason as the state religion and so this the this it took on this kind of antagonism to say to religion and and
01:17:04
the the idea that the two were in conflict and you you if you're going to be a scientist you had to be anti-religious especially anti-christian um again with materialism in the 19th century you you got a father best of of
01:17:17
this kind of materialism as a philosophy of nature which excluded all religion rendered it meaningless or useless or a waste of time uh whereas science represented progress and reason and the
01:17:30
intellectual atmosphere of universities is really shaped by this kind of Enlightenment rationalism that's the reason that they've come to be the way they are and it's part of the collective ideology
01:17:42
it's anti-religious specifically anti-christian and a materialist in its General tone there are plenty of exceptions of course and not all scientists believe this in fact recent
01:17:56
surveys show that in Britain France and Germany about 25 percent of scientists are atheists about another 20 are agnostics 45 percent classify themselves as non-religious but 45 classify
01:18:10
themselves as spiritual but not religious or spiritual or religious so actually the the if you look at the actual practicing scientific Community there's lots of people who are not part
01:18:22
of this atheist materialist worldview but they don't say so in public because they don't want to be attacked they're afraid that some dork Insight will attack them so they keep quiet whenever I give talks in universities about my
01:18:35
research on telepathy or morphic resonance invariably after the talk people come up to me and say you know I'm really interested in what you do I think but I'm interested in these things but I can't talk to my colleagues because
01:18:48
they're also straight and they're so materialistic one after another comes up to me and says the same thing and I sometimes say some don't you realize that at least 10 people in this department who think like you do and
01:19:00
they said no all right I said yes there are because they've just told me and and so I you know science would be very liberated so my model is that for people should come out that science is full of
01:19:13
closet holists or people with closet ideas on spirituality who just simply or who've had telepathic experiences or whose dogs know when they're coming home from the lab
01:19:27
um that they they just don't dare talk to their colleagues about it this is a sociological Phenomenon with historical roots I think it's bound to change partly because these these historical
01:19:38
prejudices that are built into science uh as we know it have come about through European history but the majority of scientists of the world today are not European they're Indian they're Chinese
01:19:50
they're Indonesian they're Brazilian and so on and in these cultures they have no reason at all to buy into all this baggage of European history um you know most when I worked in India as a scientist I was in an international
01:20:03
agricultural Institute most of my colleagues were Indian scientists they were Muslim Sikhs Hindus some jains some passes they came from a variety of different religious backgrounds at work
01:20:16
all of them were conventional mechanistic biologists you know with the conventional mechanistic assumptions but as soon as they got home in the evening none of them believed it they knew that that was for the you have to play the game by the rules at work if you're
01:20:29
going to keep your job but none of them were convinced mechanistic materialists in their own private lives or in their family life they just went along with that at work and
01:20:41
actually the same is true in our society here most people from nine to five Monday to Friday go along with a kind of mechanistic materialist world view because that's the official Orthodoxy the media as a educational system all
01:20:54
support that but as soon as people who in the evening at home with their friends and family or at weekends or on holiday many of them have a sense of direct connection with nature many people have
01:21:07
mystical experiences some people take psychedelics and have totally altered state subconsciousness changing their view of reality usually towards a more pan psychist view but they won't talk about this when they
01:21:20
get back to work on a Monday morning it's a sort of split sorry I couldn't hear that that's right people conform to them in private it's a bit like Russia under Brezhnev you know if you if you didn't
01:21:43
pretend to be a dialectical materialist and a Marxist you didn't get very far or China today um whereas lots of people didn't believe it and when communism collapsed in Russia how many people were true
01:21:56
communist Believers I mean there were some but they were a minority and I think the same is true of mechanistic materialism in the academic world today um and you know luckily at the weekend
01:22:08
University you don't have to pretend this is a much more open atmosphere than in most universities thank you so much all right that's all we've got time for Ripper thank you very
01:22:20
much for a great talk [Applause] [Music]
End of transcript